barrier=block
  • Vote Up0Vote Down draghetto2003draghetto2003
    I've added this node: 1375730731

    It has this tags:

    access no
    barrier block
    bicycle yes
    foot yes
    motor_vehicle no
    motorcar no
    motorcycle no

    MapFactor ignores it and calculates route through this node
  • 9 Comments sorted by
  • Vote Up0Vote Down hurdygurdymanhurdygurdyman
    When did you add that node?
    If it was later than beginning of last march it's possibly not in up to date maps and you should wait. Mapfactor normally gets OSM-planetfile at the beginning of a month, convert data and updates their maps at the end of that month.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down draghetto2003draghetto2003
    I added it on 23 February 2014
  • Vote Up0Vote Down mdxmdx
    barrier=block is not supported at the moment, sorry
  • Vote Up0Vote Down hurdygurdymanhurdygurdyman
    Ok, mdx.
    Is there a chance to get it supported.
    Thanks.p
  • Vote Up0Vote Down mdxmdx
    It is possible, but it is not trivial. It is necessary to split ways not only on junctions but also on all road blocks (if they are not on the end of the way) ... actually is the http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1375730731 meant to block entrance to "Via Settima Villaggio Prealpino (47994454)"? So would it be enough to start with block at the beginning/end of the road? (the one which is closer?)
    thanks
       Martin
  • Vote Up0Vote Down hurdygurdymanhurdygurdyman
    I think best solution would be to block that part of a road with a barrier in it from the closest junktion to other acceptable roads for the set kind of calculation for routing except the target is between the barrier and that junktion.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down draghetto2003draghetto2003
    this is my proposal: replace barrier=* nodes with access=no, and leave unchanged the others attributes
  • Vote Up0Vote Down mdxmdx
    OK - I like the proposal. At least for May 2014 conversion we will this way be able to collect "barrier data". I tried it experimentally on andorra_osm (April 2014 data) and
    +------------+---------+----------------+
    | node       | tag_key | tag_value      |
    +------------+---------+----------------+
    |   52595958 | barrier | gate           |
    |  337775428 | barrier | entrance       |
    |  394847593 | barrier | gate           |
    |  441154305 | barrier | fence          |
    |  690708580 | barrier | border_control |
    | 1477727207 | barrier | lift_gate      |
    | 1922647452 | barrier | toll_booth     |
    | 2206610569 | barrier | gate           |
    +------------+---------+----------------+

    The "border_control" sounds scary and could break routing between two neighbor countries. In this case http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/690708580  is not par of any way ... but there could be others (?!).

    Based on http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:barrier for example "barrier=entrance" should be passable. For May 2014 conversion I would choose probably only original report, i.e. "barrier=block".
    thanks for comments
       Martin

    Edit:
    p.s. here is an example of block on the end of two ways:
    http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/441154305
  • Vote Up0Vote Down draghetto2003draghetto2003
    Good news. I hope this new feature will be implemented soon on all countries! 

    thanks you
Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion