Route leads to highway exit of oncoming traffic!
-
Hello,
Edit4: Got another update for my region and MapFactor Navigator now takes the correct exit!
Edit3: The update is processed, OSRM does it correctly now but MapFactor Navigator still doesn't!
Edit2: I tried to edit the OS map, let's see if it gets updated.
Edit: Nevermind, I checked it on Openstreetmap.org and it's indeed their fault. Anybody knowledgeable about OSM and could tell me how I could fix it? The exits are one way, but how do I forbid a left turn in the map data?
http://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=osrm_car&route=48.61702,9.24942;48.62056,9.24527#map=17/48.61907/9.24915&layers=N
I'm not sure if this is an issue with the openstreemaps or Navigator for Android.
The route leads to the highway exit of the oncoming traffic.
Coordinates:
48°37'09.0"N 9°14'53.4"E
48.619167, 9.248167
Android: 4.4.2
MapFactor Navigator: 1.6.20
Let me know if you need more information, hope this can be fixed. Thanks.
-
10 Comments sorted by
-
The avoided section is flagged "one way", in the opposite direction as yours.Should this be wrong (looks like it is), you just have to flag it "two ways" instead. This is easy to do, a good way to get started with OSM :)
-
Hey, looking twice at the map, the proper way is on the right of the way suggested by the software. It's indeed a mapping issue as OSRM does the same routing: http://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=osrm_car&route=48.61739,9.24923;48.62078,9.24494#map=17/48.61907/9.24707I can't look at it further right now, but will do when I'll have a chance to.
-
my route is not going this way, I use default car settings
-
The same trouble I saw today in Be-on-road navigation /near Jihlava/... so error in maps?
-
Hi shlublu,
the "one way" flag is indeed correct! I know the street.
This is a main road and left turning is forbidden, there is an exit on the right for cars coming from the south, that is the correct way and MapQuest does it correctly
Edit: It doesn't either, if the destination is close to the exit.
I've reported the error
But then made an OSM account and edited the exit myself and forbid left turning. But the OSRM routing is still incorrect, maybe it's not yet updated.
-
Update: Some time passed since I edited the OSmap and MapFactor Navigator got a map update.
However the problem still persist! Could this be a MapFactor Navigator issue after all? Does the Navigator app understand all OSM data?
OSRM does the routing correctly now.
-
@tomas: Interesting, what could I be doing wrong? What option in the car settings could allow such an illegal navigation?
Could you post a screenshot?
-
I think so, because:
Update: I got another OSMap update for my region and now the navigation is correct!
@jmartin1: Go to openstreetmap.org and report the error or make an account and try to fix it yourself. It was surprisingly easy for me. Just had to forbid a left turn.
All the best! And thanks for the help
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
- All Discussions3,246
- Feature Requests1,264
- Bugs555
- General376
- Navigator FREE1,029
- Vehicle Tracking5
- Navigator 1017