No route available problem
  • Hi. Thanks for a wonderful app, which acts in many ways as well or in some cases even better than commercial products.

    However, I get one "no route" error, which I am not able to fix myself. The problem is on route E75 in Poland (route 1), which is still under
    construction. I know that constantly changing route organisation may
    cause some problems, it seems that this is the case: Navigator doesn't
    seem to find a route between the junction with road 71 next to Lodz and the town Tusczyn (well it does find a route, using local roads and not the
    straight primary road). The problematic segment seems to be the one,
    which crosses the Roza - Lodz Poludnie higway, which is under
    construction. I also tried enabling all the roads in the route setup
    menu. Both google and OpenStreetMaps displays the segment correctly. At least as far as I can tell - I am new to both Navigator and OpenStreetMaps.

    I know that this won't be fixed until my trip (which starts in less than a week), but it would be great, if this would be fixed in later releases. Thanks!
  • 6 Comments sorted by
  • any chance of getting co-ordinates please?
  • According to google:
    from 51.66089,19.476559
    to 51.603779,19.536698
    If the format is correct... Sorry, I don't know how to extract coordinates from navigator.
  • in OSM katowicka is oneway between motorway (under contruction) and Pabianicka
    if this is incorrect, please edit maps in openstreetmaps.
  • Thanks for your answer, however could you please explain it in more detail?

    I do not know how to check the exact maps used in Navigator, thus I refer to the current version of Moreover, I am not local and I am just planning the trip through this place, so I am not in a position to claim something or edit the maps. However, knowing that this is a road of high importance in Poland, I really doubt it would be one-way... Nevertheless I don't see, which part of the road is one-way.

    Katowicka between Pabianicka and the motorway under construction is a two-way highway with a separated traffic of opposite directions. This is represented by two parallel lines, both are one-way facing opposite directions. Before the construction site, the separation of traffic disappears and only one two way line is left. This part is composed of two sections: and both are two-way (well, oneway=no) and they fork correctly (as far as I can see) at both ends to the separated motorways.

    I also checked the history of those sections: they were marked as one-way at first, but on 18th of June they were marked as two-way and this wasn't changed later. The maps of Poland I use in Navigator are dated 29th of July.

    Now for some tests with Navigator:
    Way 5063675 next to node 2267868879 -> way 226203302, next to node 2350633095: no route
    Way 226203302, next to node 2350633095 -> way 226203488, next to node 2350640608: no route
    Way 226203302, next to node 2350633095 <-> way 226203302, next to node 2267869976: OK
    Way 226203302, next to node 2267869976 <-> way 218557725, next to node 2183582134: no route
    Way 218557725, next to node 2183582134 <-> way 218557725, next to node 2183579521: OK
    way 218557725, next to node 2183579521 -> way 230759069, next to node 2267870999: no route
    way 217507735, next to node 465570018 -> 218557725, next to node 2183579521: OK

    Way x can be found in
    Node x can be found in

    It looks to me as if the separate sections of Katowicka are not correctly connected together. But I don't see the problem in the current data: I checked through potlatch2 and also through Java OSM editor. Am I missing something?
  • it seems that this has been fixed at the end of July, so it should be OK in the next update

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion